I guess I felt Ravelry was so great because I really haven't spent much time on both. I haven't gotten the sense of "community" that everyone seems to have here simply because I haven't spent much time here. I hope that changes soon though! What caught by eye about Ravelry was the sheer volume of information. One of the books I've been having a fun time with is "Don't Knit Your Man A Sweater". It was so much fun putting the book's name in and seeing what people have been doing with the very same project I've been working on (namely Argyle Socks). Anyway, I hope to get to know some of you soon!
Rob
www.robertbrereton.com
well - ravalry is a huge resource; but in my opinion has some serious basic issues; among other things - introducing new feature after new feature when the current ones don't work correctly or only work intermittantly. The search features are very erratic - if you run the same searches you can get totally different results only minutes apart;
I personally could also do without the cutesy icons; the whole "friend" business; "favoriting" and several other features that I am sure many Ravelers consider essential.
MWK and Ravelry both have their place... and that's why I am on both :) - since discovering them, it's hard to imagine life without either of them... I will say that I have met some incredible people on Ravelry, and the sheer size of the membership has introduced me to groups/guilds, as well as even some in person meetings...
I agree that Men Who Knit most definitely has the "personal touch", I feel far less like a community on Ravelry (even in the Ravelry Men Who Knit group). But Ravelry absolutely has it's merits, especially in the organization category. The "My Notebook" features are so useful as well as the pattern and yarn browers. I also love Ravelry to check out prospective projects to find out what worked and didn't work for other people who did those projects. _____________________________ http://fiberofmybeing.blogspot.com/
I like them both...I like that ravelry has so many rooms of interest, and that I can pick the brains of people (men AND women) who have worked on various projects that I might be interested in...(for example, there are a lot more garment designers on there, and good resources for sample knitters, getting pieces published etc...) MWK is like a coffee klatch knit group... Both have great attributes, but they're kind of hard to compare: They don't try to be the same things.
Ditto .. Ravelry is fun to visit from time to time, but this smaller forum is much better. I visit MWK several times a day. The smaller and more specific men's forum is a much better place.
I, like Joe, Albert, and Mario feel more connected to this forum. I was excited when I got my invitiation and started putting all my things in but I soon realized that I had lost months of valuable knitting time. It is fun to travel through the different groups but really it is like an Ice Cream store with 60,000 flavours!!
Me three. I like the smaller forums, it's like the difference between a house concert with 20 or thirty people and a mass concert with 8 or ten thousand.
MMario - ambiguity is cultivated, it doesn't happen in a vacuum!
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MMarioKKnits/
I agree completely with Albert. Ravelry has some great features and functionality, but I don't feel much closeness with masses of folks like I do with the guys out here.
ilhiker: Billknits: I can show you how to post pictures of knitted projects if you like. Just send me an email and we can start there.1 week 3 days ago
Billknits: how does one post pictures of knitted projects-- little challanged here2 weeks 4 days ago
daninaa: I think that "queerjoe" has a pattern on his blog page2 weeks 4 days ago
Billknits: Des any one know where I can get a pattern for mens boxers?2 weeks 4 days ago
Crafty Andy: I just notice we got shouts once more lol3 weeks 2 days ago
Crafty Andy: Thank You Bill3 weeks 2 days ago
Bill: HAPPY BIRTHDAY, ANDY!3 weeks 5 days ago
KenInMaine: Working on finishing up the Girasole. The lace edging is taking a long time but I'm happy with how it's shaping up....3 weeks 6 days ago
ilhiker: Here is the flooding where I live. http://www.desplaines.org/mediacenter.aspx?VID=37#allVideos4 weeks 5 days ago
Comments
I guess I felt Ravelry was
I guess I felt Ravelry was so great because I really haven't spent much time on both. I haven't gotten the sense of "community" that everyone seems to have here simply because I haven't spent much time here. I hope that changes soon though! What caught by eye about Ravelry was the sheer volume of information. One of the books I've been having a fun time with is "Don't Knit Your Man A Sweater". It was so much fun putting the book's name in and seeing what people have been doing with the very same project I've been working on (namely Argyle Socks). Anyway, I hope to get to know some of you soon!
Rob
www.robertbrereton.com
well - ravalry is a huge
well - ravalry is a huge resource; but in my opinion has some serious basic issues; among other things - introducing new feature after new feature when the current ones don't work correctly or only work intermittantly. The search features are very erratic - if you run the same searches you can get totally different results only minutes apart;
I personally could also do without the cutesy icons; the whole "friend" business; "favoriting" and several other features that I am sure many Ravelers consider essential.
MWK and Ravelry both have
MWK and Ravelry both have their place... and that's why I am on both :) - since discovering them, it's hard to imagine life without either of them... I will say that I have met some incredible people on Ravelry, and the sheer size of the membership has introduced me to groups/guilds, as well as even some in person meetings...
all in all, they're both good in their own way :)
www.kyleknits.blogspot.com
yes, Ravelry does have it's
yes, Ravelry does have it's uses.
I agree that Men Who Knit
I agree that Men Who Knit most definitely has the "personal touch", I feel far less like a community on Ravelry (even in the Ravelry Men Who Knit group). But Ravelry absolutely has it's merits, especially in the organization category. The "My Notebook" features are so useful as well as the pattern and yarn browers. I also love Ravelry to check out prospective projects to find out what worked and didn't work for other people who did those projects. _____________________________
http://fiberofmybeing.blogspot.com/
Is it OK for me to prefer
Is it OK for me to prefer this site to the 'wimmin's' groups?
as long as you encourage
as long as you encourage us!
MMario - ambiguity is cultivated, it doesn't happen in a vacuum!
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MMarioKKnits/
That I will definitely do!
That I will definitely do!
I like them both...I like
I like them both...I like that ravelry has so many rooms of interest, and that I can pick the brains of people (men AND women) who have worked on various projects that I might be interested in...(for example, there are a lot more garment designers on there, and good resources for sample knitters, getting pieces published etc...) MWK is like a coffee klatch knit group... Both have great attributes, but they're kind of hard to compare: They don't try to be the same things.
Bob
("Badger" on Ravelry)
Ditto .. Ravelry is fun to
Ditto .. Ravelry is fun to visit from time to time, but this smaller forum is much better. I visit MWK several times a day. The smaller and more specific men's forum is a much better place.
I, like Joe, Albert, and
I, like Joe, Albert, and Mario feel more connected to this forum. I was excited when I got my invitiation and started putting all my things in but I soon realized that I had lost months of valuable knitting time. It is fun to travel through the different groups but really it is like an Ice Cream store with 60,000 flavours!!
Me three. I like the
Me three. I like the smaller forums, it's like the difference between a house concert with 20 or thirty people and a mass concert with 8 or ten thousand.
MMario - ambiguity is cultivated, it doesn't happen in a vacuum!
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MMarioKKnits/
There's alot there- sort of
There's alot there- sort of like a big box store. MWK is cozier.
I agree completely with
I agree completely with Albert. Ravelry has some great features and functionality, but I don't feel much closeness with masses of folks like I do with the guys out here.
Ditto.
Ditto.